The 1984 Buccaneer draft review
2
Keith
Browner
3
Fred
Acorn
4
Micheal
Gunter
4
Ron
Heller
6
Chris
Washington
7
Jay
Carroll
8
Fred
Robinson
9
Rick
Mallory
10
Jim
Gallery
11
Blair
Kiel
12
Thad
Jemison

RdSelectionPos
1traded to Cincinnati in 1983 for QB Jack Thompson
2Keith BrownerLB
3Fred AcornCB
4traded to San Francisco in 1983
4Micheal GunterRB
4(from Oakland) Ron HellerT
4(from San Diego) to Denver for QB Steve DeBerg
5traded to Dallas for LB Danny Spradlin
6Chris WashingtonLB
7Jay CarrollTE
8Fred RobinsonDE
9Rick MalloryG
10Jim GalleryPK
11Blair KielQB
12Thad JemisonWR
Click here to review the entire 1984 NFL draft
The Bucs drafted No.1 throughout the rounds of this draft. The Bucs gained three additional fourth round picks, the first from the David Lewis trade back in 1982 with San Diego, the second again from San Diego from LB Dewey Selmon. and the other from the Raiders for Charley Hannah. The Lewis pick was used in the deal to net Steve DeBerg from the Denver Broncos. Their own pick was traded to San Francisco a year earlier for a 1983 6th round selection on draft day.

1 - traded to Cincinnati in 1983 for QB Jack Thompson - Terrible trade
The Bucs needed a quarterback bad after Doug Williams left. What they got was a bad quarterback. Thompson had been a bust with the Bengals for four years and gleefully accepted the first-round pick the Bucs offered for him. The Bucs proceeded to go 2-14 under Thompson and Cincinnati wound up with the first overall pick in the 1984 draft.

2 - LB - Keith Browner - USC - Poor pick
Browner had great pedigree in that his two elder brothers were both first round picks and good players and that he looked good at USC. But his three years in Tampa were far short of that and he wound up playing in the Arena League.

3 - CB - Fred Acorn - Texas - Poor pick
Played one season in Tampa and was then cut the following season. He was part of the entire Texas Longhorn secondary that was drafted in the first five rounds that year, one of whom, Craig Curry, also went on to play for the Buccaneers.

4 - RB - Micheal Gunter - Tulsa - Wasted pick
Never played a down for the Buccaneers. Did rush 15 times for 12 yards in four late-season appearances for the Chiefs that year. The unusual spelling of his first name is correct and not a misprint.

4 - T - Ron Heller - Penn State - Good pick
A real solid hard-working tackle who would have been a fixture in Tampa if it hadn't been for Ray Perkins' pig-headedness. Heller went on to play several more years in Miami and Philadelphia.

4 - traded to Denver for QB Steve DeBerg - Good trade
DeBerg started for most of 1984 and led the Bucs to what remained their highest offensive ranking in their first 35 years. He was with the Bucs through 1987 and was a lot better value than the first round pick that was given up for his predecessor Jack Thompson.

5 - traded to Dallas for LB Danny Spradlin - Average trade
Never broke regularly into the starting line-up and remained the same sort of player he was in Dallas, a special teamer. Did rank second on the team in special teams' tackles in both of his two seasons and did make two starts when the Bucs were decimated by injuries.

6 - LB - Chris Washington - Iowa State - Good pick
Played five seasons in Tampa and was a starter for three of them. Always more a pass-rush specialist than a coverage guy but a really solid pick in the middle of the draft.

7 - TE - Jay Carroll - Minnesota - Average pick
Made the roster and played in every game as a rookie, albeit as the No.3 tight end behind Jimmie Giles and Jerry Bell. Was beaten out of the job by Calvin Magee the following season and never played in the NFL again.

8 - DE - Fred Robinson - Miami - Wasted pick
Never played a down for the Buccaneers. Played three seasons in the NFL, two in San Diego and one in Miami, recording 14.5 sacks in his 46 game NFL career. Had eight sacks in his senior year at Miami and helped them win the national title in the memorable Orange Bowl game v Nebraska.

9 - G - Rick Mallory - Washington - Good pick
Worked his way into a starting role for two seasons but then retired from football in 1988 to run his own construction company. Missed his entire rookie season through injury and now coaches offensive line at the University of Memphis.

10 - PK - Jim Gallery - Minnesota - Wasted pick
Never played a down for the Buccaneers. Did play for the Cardinals for a time in the NFL however and also saw action in 1989 with the Bengals and two games in Minnesota the following year.

11 - QB - Blair Kiel - Notre Dame - OK pick
Saw playing time only as a holder on kicks in the NFL. Made the team following a great pre-season and also served as the Bucs' back-up kicker and punter that year. Was a friend of Jon Gruden in college as his father Jim Gruden was coaching at Notre Dame in the early 1980s.

12 - WR - Thad Jemison - Ohio State - Wasted pick
Never played a down for the Buccaneers. Never played football in the NFL at all. Only had 43 career receptions in college, 27 of which came as a senior. Was drafted on the back of his Fiesta Bowl performance v Pittsburgh when he caught eight passes for 131 yards and the winning touchdown.

Summing up 1984
An absolutely appalling draft. The chance for the first overall pick was traded away, Browner and Acorn were busts and not a single player was still on the roster five years later. Leeman Bennett may have been a bad coach but he got no help from John McKay's final draft for the Buccaneers.